WHAT WE DO
From routine cleanings to same-day emergencies, every visit is built around you—not a checklist.
Straighten your teeth using sets of clear aligners rather than traditional braces. Complimentary consultation available.
Cavity treatment with composite white fillings that look natural and conserve more tooth structure than silver fillings.
Dental crowns (caps) cover an entire tooth and can be made of porcelain, metal alloys, or a combination. Used to strengthen teeth or improve appearance.
ZOOM! Whitening and bleach trays are simple, safe and effective options.
Quick and swift tooth extraction with proper numbing to ensure patient comfort.
Treatment for when a cavity is so deep that it reaches the inner layer of the tooth.
Natural-looking replacements for lost permanent teeth that restore normal chewing abilities.
Implants can be used to replace one or more missing permanent teeth.
Stop the destruction of bone with periodontal therapy better known as scaling and root planning or a 'deep cleaning'.
Emergency dental care for severe toothache, chipped or broken tooth, broken bridge, loose or missing crown, gum soreness or bleeding, and broken dentures.
TAP (Thorton Adjustable Positioner) for patients diagnosed with mild or moderate sleep apnea who have issues with CPAP.
MEET YOUR DENTISTS
Scarlet Dental provides complete and high quality dental care in a family friendly office. They offer same day appointments and are accepting new patients, providing each and every patient with superior quality dental care in a fun and friendly environment.
Owner / Dentist
Dr. Vincer owns Scarlet Dental in both Pickerington and Zanesville. Graduated from Saint Mary's of Notre Dame and The Ohio State University with her doctorate in dental surgery. She is an adjunct professor for The Ohio State University's College of Dentistry. Received ADA's 10 Under 10 Award in 2022 and Columbus Business First's 40 Under 40 in 2017. Volunteers at Maasai Dental Clinic in Kenya, Columbus Health Department extraction clinic, hosts ADA's Give Kids A Smile event annually, and educates children on oral hygiene at schools and childcare centers.
"She actually cares about her patients"
Dentist
Dr. Haldeman began at Scarlet Dental in 2019. Prior to that he owned a private practice focused on cosmetic and restorative dentistry. The staff has nick named him Dr. Wonderful. He has a passion for dentistry and is known for corny Dad/Grandpa jokes. He has 2 adult sons and 4 grandchildren who live locally.
"An amazing staff"
American Dental Association's 10 Under 10 Award (2022)
Columbus Business First's 40 Under 40 (2017)
PATIENT STORIES
★★★★★
"An amazing staff! An emergency, they worked me in, and staff stayed after hours to complete the temporary work. Not sure this happens in other offices, but it is in this one, and that is but one reason I will recommend this practice to every I know."
— Teresa T.
★★★★★
"The staff is so friendly and welcoming. I am never nervous going to the dentist anymore. Dr. Vincer and her hygienist's are professional, thorough and very easy to talk to. I would recommend this practice to anyone looking for a new dentist."
— Julie F.
★★★★★
"What a great office! Can't say enough about how great Dr. Vincer and her staff are at making you feel comfortable. My 4 kids love her!"
— Kelly N.
★★★★★
"I have never been at a dental office where I felt the sincerity the staff really cared about me, I was not just a number... It is very rare to find an entire office to genuinely care for each patient!"
— Dan L.
★★★★★
"I love, love, love this office. The staff is amazing - friendly, efficient and educational. My teeth look amazing when I leave, but I also always walk away with a little bit more 'dental education' then when I arrived."
— Anonymous
WHY SCARLET DENTAL
Got a toothache this morning? Call by 8 AM and you can be in the chair today. No waiting weeks—Scarlet Dental keeps same-day slots open specifically for urgent needs.
No dental insurance? Scarlet Dental offers reduced fees for uninsured patients so cost never stands between your family and the care you need.
Dr. Vincer received the American Dental Association's 10 Under 10 Award in 2022—recognition given to dentists who demonstrate excellence within their first 10 years of practice.
Dr. Vincer teaches at The Ohio State University's College of Dentistry. Your dentist literally trains the next generation of dentists—that's the level of knowledge behind your treatment plan.
When Teresa T. had an emergency, the staff stayed after hours to finish her temporary work. That's not a policy in a manual—it's the culture of this practice.
Every year, Dr. Vincer hosts the ADA's Give Kids A Smile event and visits local schools and childcare centers to teach children about oral hygiene. This is a dental office rooted in its community.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Monday through Thursday: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM. Friday: 8:00 AM – 3:00 PM. Closed Saturday and Sunday. Same-day appointments are available if you call early.
We're at 107 W. Columbus St., Pickerington, Ohio 43147—right on Columbus Street in the heart of Pickerington's historic district. Easy to find with plenty of nearby parking.
Scarlet Dental offers discounted fees for patients without dental insurance. We also accept Medicaid. No one should skip dental care because of cost—talk to our front desk about options when you schedule.
Patients consistently say they feel like a person here, not a number. As Julie F. put it: "I am never nervous going to the dentist anymore." Dr. Vincer and the team are known for making sure you're numb and comfortable before any procedure begins—and for talking you through every step.
Absolutely. Kelly N. brings all four of her kids and says they love Dr. Vincer. This is a family practice built for all ages. Dr. Vincer also hosts the ADA's annual Give Kids A Smile event and visits local schools to teach children about oral hygiene.
Customers choose Scarlet Dental for Dr. Katie Vincer Sears' expertise, the caring and amazing staff experience from front desk to dentist, comfortable care environment, and acceptance of all insurance and Medicaid. No other Pickerington practice combines an ADA award-winning, OSU-faculty dentist with same-day availability and discounted uninsured pricing under one roof.
Yes. Dr. Vincer received the American Dental Association's 10 Under 10 Award in 2022, recognizing outstanding young dentists. She was also named to Columbus Business First's 40 Under 40 in 2017. She holds a DDS from The Ohio State University and currently serves as an adjunct professor at OSU's College of Dentistry.
GET IN TOUCH
107 W. Columbus St.
Pickerington, Ohio 43147